Choosing the right printable sticker paper can be a daunting task, given the overwhelming amount of options flooding the market. In this video, I take on the challenge by testing five different popular brands of printable sticker paper and vinyl. By the end of this blog post, you’ll have a clear understanding of which options stand out, ensuring you make informed decisions for your sticker making endeavors.
Watch the video below to see what happened!
1. Joyeza Vinyl Sticker Paper: The Budget-Friendly Winner
Starting with Joyeza Vinyl Sticker Paper, this Amazon bestseller immediately catches the eye with its impressive stats—over 15,000 reviews, 4.5 stars, and an affordable price of $12.97 for 25 sheets (51 cents per sheet). The bright white paper, crystal-clear stickers, and vibrant colors make it a strong contender for any Cricut enthusiast.
2. TeckWrap Printable Sticker Vinyl: Slightly Bigger, Equally Impressive
TeckWrap’s Printable Sticker Vinyl, priced at $18.99 for 28 sheets (67 cents per sheet), exhibits qualities similar to Joyeza’s. The paper, though not as bright, boasts a larger size measuring 8.26″ x 11.69″. This provides slightly more printable area at the bottom of the page, although you might have difficulty printing on that longer length printer. When I tried printing designs on this paper, my printer cut off the design after 11″.
3. TeckWrap Holographic Sticker Paper: A Dazzling Disappointment
The TeckWrap Holographic Rainbow Sticker Paper, while visually stunning, encountered printing issues, leading to a disappointing experience. No matter how many times I tried, I could not get my printer to properly feed this paper into the printer. Half of my stickers were always cut off, rendering the paper a total waste.
I’m not sure if this is more of a problem with my printer or the paper itself, but I couldn’t get this paper to print with my inkjet printer. Priced at $18.99 for 28 sheets (67 cents per sheet), this is one of the more costly types of printable sticker paper. The holographic features were stunning and I was disappointed that I couldn’t get this paper to work.
4. Cricut Printable Sticker Paper: A Failed Legacy
The older version of Cricut Printable Sticker Paper faced significant drawbacks, being too thick and troublesome to print. This paper was so thick and stiff that it didn’t bend at all when held in my hand. Because of this extreme thickness, my printer would get jammed with every attempt. Priced at $10.68 for 12 sheets (89 cents per sheet), this was the priciest and least printer friendly option. Note that Cricut may have updated this product, so check for newer versions.
5. Cricut Printable Vinyl: Consistent Quality at a Price
Cricut Printable Vinyl, priced at $10.68 for 12 sheets (89 cents per sheet), performed well, offering consistent quality. I had no trouble at all getting it to print and the quality was great. Though slightly more expensive, it delivered satisfactory results, making it a reliable choice for those loyal to the Cricut brand.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Joyeza Vinyl Sticker Paper emerged as the budget-friendly winner, combining affordability with excellent print quality. TeckWrap Printable Sticker Vinyl and Cricut Printable Vinyl also held their ground, each with its strengths. However, caution is advised when considering TeckWrap Holographic Sticker Paper and the older version of Cricut Printable Sticker Paper due to potential printing challenges.
Remember, the right choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. I hope this comprehensive review helps you navigate the sticker paper maze, enabling you to embark on your crafting journey with confidence. Share your favorite sticker paper brand in the comments and happy crafting!
Looking for something to read next? Learn what else your Cricut machine can do. Before you become a Cricut expert, learn what not to do in my 10 Biggest Mistakes New Cricut Owners Make article. Or if you’ve already made something beautiful you want to sell, check out How To Get Better Pictures Of Your Cricut Projects Using Product Mockups
